Industry View: Cautiously Bearish (12 months, medium confidence) | Report Date: 2026-11-16 Scope of Research: Mines, ore dressing, safety and environmental compliance, and new projects capable of economically producing acid-grade fluorspar (CaF2 ≥97% concentrate); utilization of associated/tailings resources; downstream hydrofluoric acid–fluorochemicals demand (refrigerant quotas as background only); global market coverage (China as the pricing center).
Core Conclusions
Fluorspar (fluorite, CaF2) is classified by grade into metallurgical grade (CaF2 <97%, for steel slagging/casting-welding materials/cement glass, approx. 35-42% of all fluorspar) and acid grade (CaF2 ≥97% concentrate, obtained by flotation, used to make hydrofluoric acid). This report focuses on mines and ore-dressing operations that can economically produce acid-grade fluorspar. One-sentence industry chain map:
Fluorspar mine (mining & dressing) → acid-grade concentrate (≥97%) → anhydrous hydrofluoric acid AHF (approx. 2.2 tons of fluorspar/ton) → refrigerants (HFC/HFO, quota system, background only) / fluoropolymers (PTFE, PVDF, etc.) / lithium battery electrolytes (LiPF6, LiFSI) / electronic-grade HF and fluorinated specialty gases / aluminum fluoride salts (AlF3, cryolite).
Geographic boundary: global market. In 2025, global fluorspar production was approx. 10 million tons (USGS), with China at 6 million tons (60%), Mexico 1.5 million tons, Mongolia 1.5 million tons (mainly metallurgical grade, acid grade only approx. 8%), South Africa 410k tons, Vietnam 160k tons; on an acid-grade basis, China produced approx. 4.03 million tons (2024, SMM), approx. 73% of the global total — China is the marginal pricing market for acid-grade fluorspar, and Mongolian imports are its marginal supply.
| End Market | Share of Acid-Grade Demand | Growth and Logic |
|---|---|---|
| Fluorocarbon chemicals (refrigerants and feedstocks; quotas as background only: China's 2024 HFC production quota 749k tons) | Approx. 28-30% | +1~3%/yr: R22 phase-down offsets R32 growth; aftermarket steadily grows; export-side sensitivities of -30~-50k tons from India's anti-dumping sunset review and Middle East self-sufficiency |
| Lithium battery electrolytes (LiPF6+LiFSI) | 2024 approx. 15% → 2028E approx. 20% | LiPF6 shipments of 208k tons in 2024 (+23.1%, EVTank); price 105k yuan/ton in March 2026 (+87.5% YoY); EVTank forecasts 687k tons by 2030 |
| Fluoropolymers (PTFE/PVDF/FEP/FKM) | Approx. 10-12% | +5~8%/yr; battery-grade PVDF approx. 94k tons in 2024; 3M completed its PFAS manufacturing exit by end-2025, share shifting to Chinese producers |
| Semiconductor/electronic-grade HF, fluorinated specialty gases, fluorinated fine chemicals | Approx. 10-12% | +8~10%/yr: etching/cleaning/precursors trace back to HF, irreplaceable; data center immersion cooling fluorinated fluids still small (2030E global market approx. USD 3.2 billion) |
| Aluminum smelting fluoride salts (AlF3/cryolite) | Approx. 15-20% | +1.5~2%/yr: AlF3 unit consumption 15-20 kg/ton of aluminum, global electrolytic aluminum approx. 72 million tons |
| (Background) Metallurgical grade: steel slagging, etc. | 35-42% of all fluorspar | Fluctuates with the steel cycle, unit consumption declining, many substitutes; not the core of this report's pricing |
Regionally, China accounts for approx. 60-65% of global consumption (chemical uses approx. 75% of China's fluorspar demand); US apparent consumption is 390k tons, 100% import-dependent; Europe is a net importer. China is the dual center of both demand and marginal pricing for acid-grade fluorspar.
2024 base year of 6 million tons (Project Blue: 2024 acid-grade supply >6 million tons, via IMFORMED), under central assumptions (LiPF6 2028 shipments of 400k tons, central unit consumption of 2.6 tons of fluorspar/ton):
Balance: 600 +16 +50 +6.2 +7.5 +7.9 +2 +14.4 −20 −5 = 6.79 million tons (CAGR approx. 3.1%). The largest uncertainty is the LiPF6 assumption: unit consumption ranges from 2.05 (stoichiometric) — 2.6 (central) — 5.4 (high market estimate) tons of fluorspar/ton, with 2028 shipments of 320-500k tons — under the low case, 2028E demand is approx. 6.5 million tons (CAGR 2%); under the high case, 7.0-7.2 million tons (CAGR 5%+). This report uses 6.79 million tons as the central estimate and a 6.5-7.2 million ton range as the decision band.
Structural vs. Cyclical: The battery chain (salts + PVDF, gross increment approx. 640k tons) and semiconductor/electronics (+79k tons) are penetration-driven and cross-cycle; refrigerants (+160k tons) and aluminum fluoride salts (+144k tons) have stable volumes with cyclical prices. A precedent for cyclical give-back: the 2022-2024 deep fall in LiPF6/PVDF sharply cut downstream operating rates (refrigerant industry capacity utilization once at 66.4%, independent HF approx. 58%) — high prices themselves are a demand suppressant (-50k tons already counted in the bridge).
In 2025, global fluorspar production was approx. 10 million tons (-1% YoY, USGS MCS 2026), of which acid grade approx. 5.5 million tons. China's capacity is approx. 7.75 million tons (2023, SMM citing SRK), but effective output is suppressed by safety rectifications: of 744 mining rights at end-2023, only 154 were in production (approx. 21% operating rate); operating mines' approved capacity was 10.5945 million tons with actual extraction of 6.1888 million tons — operating capacity utilization approx. 58% (China Mining Magazine). In other words: approx. 590 idle mining rights form a potential resumption elasticity pool, and the "resource-depletion-type shortage" claim needs discounting.
| Mine/Project | Ownership | Capacity (Acid-Grade) | Cost Position (yuan/ton concentrate, cash) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baotou Steel Jinshi (Bayan Obo tailings recovery) | Jinshi Resource × Baotou Steel | 2025 output 801.1k tons; 2026 target 700-750k tons | <800 (tailings re-processing, no mining stage) | Far left of the global cost curve; approx. 77% supplied internally to Jin'eebo HF |
| Nui Phao (Vietnam) | Masan | Approx. 200k tons/yr | Near zero after tungsten by-product credits | Q4 2025 quarterly output >60k tons |
| Karqi'ar (Ruoqiang, Xinjiang) | Xinjiang Xinxin Mining (3833.HK) | Designed 295k tons/yr (1.2 million tons ore, 80% recovery) | Cash 1,459; breakeven 1,827 (SRK) | Feed trial production Sep 2025, full production only from Nov 2026, full ramp in 2027 |
| Jinshi standalone mines (Zhejiang/Inner Mongolia) | Jinshi Resource | 400-450k tons/yr | Approx. 1,600 (company disclosure) | Zhejiang underground mines fully suspended for review May 2026, H1 output -23.7%, resumed Sep-Oct |
| Las Cuevas (Mexico) | Koura/Orbia | Approx. 600-630k tons/yr | Est. 1,100-1,800 (to be verified) | World's largest single acid-grade mine; renewal risk rising under Mexico's 2023 mining reform |
| Vergenoeg/Nokeng (South Africa) | Minersa/SepFluor | Combined designed approx. 420k tons/yr | Est. 1,800-2,500 (to be verified) | Nokeng has yet to reach designed capacity years after startup |
| Bor-Undur etc. (Mongolia) | Mongolrostsvetmet etc. | Mongolia total 1.5 million tons (mainly metallurgical, acid grade approx. 8%) | Est. 1,400-2,100 (to be verified) | Of China's 856k tons of imports in H1 2025, 86% came from Mongolia |
The 90th percentile is approx. 2,600-3,000 yuan/ton (China's tail of small mines + Western restarts); at the current price of 3,588 yuan/ton the whole industry is profitable, with only Western restart mines barely at cash breakeven. Resource end: global reserves 330 million tons (USGS 2026), China 110 million tons (33%), Mexico 68 million tons, South Africa 41 million tons, Mongolia 34 million tons; global reserve-to-production ratio approx. 33 years, China approx. 18.3 years. China's eastern high-quality standalone veins are indeed depleting (mine count fell from 1,200+ to 650 over decades, only 154 in production), with new resources shifting to Inner Mongolia/Xinjiang and comprehensive tailings utilization — this raises the cost center and policy threshold, not a production cliff.
New acid-grade equivalent of approx. 600-910k tons/yr in 2026-2028 (10.8%-16.4% of existing capacity), of which approx. 70% is concentrated in three projects: Karqi'ar 295k tons (full ramp 2027), Jinshi's Mongolian Minglida 200-300k tons (still in commissioning as of Q3 2026 with only minor concentrate output; realization uncertain), and Canada's St. Lawrence ramping up to 200k tons/yr (only 8,500 tons actually produced in 2025; two historical bankruptcies; ramp-up in doubt); others include US Ares Utah 50k tons (built end-2025), Mongolia's Dai Uul 65-90k tons (timing undefined). Greenfield cycles remain long (5-10+ years in the West: St. Lawrence took approx. 12 years from restart attempt to resumption; South Africa's Doornhoek has been "about to be approved" since 2017 without landing), while China's large incumbents can compress this to 1.5-2 years.
Safety and environment are a persistent constraint: since March 2024, a nationwide special rectification of fluorspar mine safety ("close and exit a batch, consolidate and merge a batch, upgrade and transform a batch," 264 major hazards identified); Zhejiang's underground fluorspar mines were suspended province-wide for review in May 2026, resuming progressively Sep-Oct — regulators have formed an annualized suspension-resumption cycle, the largest source of near-term price elasticity. Ecological redlines, tiered tailings pond supervision, associated radioactivity (Th/U in some deposits), and mining rights transfer fees (2.4% of sales for mineral processing products) systematically raise compliance costs. Fluorspar has no national extraction quota (unlike rare earths/tungsten), but after being listed in the strategic minerals catalog, new mining rights are concentrating among large consolidators.
The Bayan Obo model is the world's most important associated supply: Baotou Steel's tailings pond holds approx. 200 million tons of tailings containing approx. 43.92 million tons of fluorspar; Baotou Steel Jinshi's three lines produced 801.1k tons of concentrate in 2025 and sold 822.9k tons (818.1k tons supplied directly to Jin'eebo for AHF), with no mining stage and costs <800 yuan/ton — essentially turning "rare earth/iron ore processing waste" into acid-grade supply at the far left of the cost curve. Nui Phao (tungsten) and Vergenoeg (iron oxide) are analogous. Phosphate-rock associated fluorine (the fluosilicic acid route) is both associated utilization and a substitution path; see D3.
| Year | Demand | Supply (Mine acid-grade + FSA equivalent) | Gap (Supply − Demand) | % of Demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 585 | 574 (540+34) | -11 | -1.9% |
| 2024 | 600 | 595 (554+41) | -5 | -0.8% |
| 2025 | 616 | 595 (550+45) | -21 | -3.4% |
| 2026E | 632 | 620 (571+49) | -12 | -1.9% |
| 2027E | 650 | 655 (600+55) | +5 | +0.8% |
| 2028E | 679 | 695 (630+65) | +16 | +2.4% |
Notes: On the supply side, FSA equivalent is the fluorspar equivalent of AHF made from phosphate-rock fluosilicic acid (2025: China 180k tons AHF ≈ 380k tons + US 73k tons); 2026E is deeper than the optimistic expectation (gap -5) because Karqi'ar reaches full production only in Nov 2026, Baotou Steel Jinshi's target was lowered to 700-750k tons, and Minglida is still commissioning; the 2027-2028 turn positive relies on the three projects reaching full ramp + Mongolian import lines + FSA expansion, but each quarter of ramp-up delay pushes loosening back one quarter. The 2028E gap range is -50 to +450k tons, determined by D2 (LiPF6 trajectory and unit consumption) and D3 (FSA pace) — the direction of the balance turning from negative to positive is the base-case judgment; the magnitude is highly uncertain.
Current price 3,588 yuan/ton (2026-11-13, Baichuan Yingfu 97% wet powder delivered-to-plant average; North China 3,300-3,430, East China ex-works 3,650-3,750; 100ppi's Nov 10 reference price 3,693.75 yuan/ton, +0.51% week-over-week — spot remains firm). International comparison: US acid-grade average import price 2021-2025 at 322/387/428/464/470 USD/ton (USGS), a record high in 2025; 2026 Asian parity assessed at approx. 600-620 USD/ton CIF (via IMARC, to be verified against primary Fastmarkets data).
Cycle Templates (Three Rounds): ① 2010-2015: panic buying + rectification, US average import price rose to approx. 1,000 USD/ton (to be verified) followed by a 3-4 year bear market; ② 2016-2020: environmental inspections, domestic price 1,400→3,675 yuan/ton (Nov 2018 peak, +162.5%), falling back to approx. 2,300; ③ 2021-2026 (current): new energy demand + normalized rectification, 2,300→3,773 (June 2024, +64%), then a highland sideways range of 3,300-3,800 yuan/ton for approx. 2.5 years — the pattern has shifted from "sharp peaks and deep troughs" to a "highland": the floor raised by costs and regulation, the ceiling capped by Mongolian imports and demand destruction. We are currently in the later stage of the third highland.
Price Formation Mechanism and Inventory Proxies: Fluorspar has no futures or exchange inventories; Chinese spot spot transactions are the marginal pricing anchor, with mine-HF producer annual/semi-annual contracts as a stabilizing layer (spot premium over contracts approx. 5-10%); inventory proxies show "neutral-tight": industry inventories low, mine operating rate only 21%, HF operating rate approx. 58%, but China's H1 2025 imports +48% (856k tons, 86% Mongolia) have substantively filled the gap — no inventory build pressure, nor evidence of shortage.
Base-case price path (12 months): pricing framework = 90th-percentile cost floor of 2,600–3,000 + import parity lower bound of 2,800–3,200 + balance direction (2026 gap narrowing → turning positive in 2027H2) + neutral inventories/low operating rates.
| Quarter | Pivot (yuan/ton) | Range | Logic |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026Q4 | 3,550 | 3,450–3,700 | Seasonal shutdown of northern mines in winter + continued remediation + firm spot, but high imports cap upside |
| 2027Q1 | 3,480 | 3,350–3,600 | Spring Festival off-season; first volume quarter after Karchar full ramp-up, Jinshi at full production after restart |
| 2027Q2 | 3,430 | 3,250–3,600 | Minlidacompletes commissioning, Mongolian flotation lines ramping, spot–long-term contract premium narrows |
| 2027Q3 | 3,400 | 3,200–3,550 | Balance explicitly turns positive; FSA expansion and St. Lawrence ramp-up suppress rebounds |
12-month pivot change of roughly -4.2%; consistent with the scenario probability-weighted expectation (3,460 yuan/ton, -3.6%). Upside triggers: expanded and escalated remediation, Mongolian border/rainy-season logistics disruption, delivery of high LiPF6 unit consumption. Downside triggers: early full ramp of the three projects, FSA outperformance, refrigerant export restrictions and demand destruction in lithium batteries.
The chart above is on a country basis: CR3 = 90% (China, Mexico, Mongolia; 2025 production). But on a company basis the industry is highly fragmented (different from the country basis; do not mix them): global company CR3 is roughly 17–18%, CR5 roughly 20% (Jinshi Resources roughly 12.2%, world No. 1; Mongolrostsvetmet roughly 4% (estimated); Masan roughly 1.5%). On a Chinese company basis, CR3 is only roughly 23% (Jinshi 20.3%), with 650 mines in a small-and-scattered pattern. Fluorspar is a strategic minor metal characterized by "high country-level concentration, low company-level concentration."
| Segment | Scale/Profit Anchor | Profitability | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fluorspar mining (Chinese acid-grade, roughly 11.4 billion yuan/year revenue) | Jinshi Resources 2025 net profit attributable to parent 326 million yuan; first three quarters of 2026 -21 million yuan (-109%) | High-quality underground mines gross margin 30–50%; Jinshi blended gross margin roughly 20% | Weakening in 2026: price decline + shutdowns + Mongolian project expenses |
| Tailings recovery (Baosteel-Jinshi) | 2025 sales of 822,900 tons, cost <800 yuan/ton | Thick per-ton gross margin, but attributable profit during ramp/depreciation phase only 158 million yuan (roughly 192 yuan/ton) | Low-cost second growth curve; 2026 target cut to 700,000–750,000 tons |
| Anhydrous hydrofluoric acid (independent) | Jin'ebo HF gross margin 5.73% (2025), 6.39% (2026H1); industry operating rate roughly 58% | Marginal profit | Squeezed at both ends; fragile |
| Refrigerants (quota) | Four companies' combined 2025 net profit attributable to parent roughly 7.92 billion yuan (Juhua 3,783M + Sanmei 2,061M + Dongyue roughly 1,510M converted to RMB + Yonghe 562M) | Sanmei gross margin 50.6%, ROE 28.4%; Juhua ROE 19.8% | High plateau; growth converging in first three quarters of 2026 (Juhua +5.3%, Sanmei +2.4%) |
Mechanism: Since 2024, the HFC quota system has locked down refrigerant supply (2026 quota of 798,000 tons, YoY <+1%; top-six concentration >95%, Juhua roughly 38%). R32 rose from roughly 17,000 yuan/ton in early 2024 to roughly 65,000 yuan/ton in 2026 (about 3.8x), while fluorspar concentrate flat-lined at 3,300–3,700 yuan/ton over the same period — nearly all of the price windfall was captured by quota holders (7.92 billion vs 326 million ≈ 24x). Bargaining power across the chain: miners, facing 650 scattered suppliers plus Mongolian import supplements, have neutral-to-weak bargaining power vs HF producers; quota holders can squeeze both HF producers and miners; Jinshi, with 77% internal supply to its self-built HF plant (Jin'ebo, 300,000 tons), has pursued backward integration to compensate for its lack of bargaining power. Over the next 2–3 years: the quota profit pool is locked at high levels but hard to expand (Kigali cuts begin in 2029); incremental profits migrate to low-cost resources (tailings/by-product) and electronic-grade/new-energy high-end fluorochemicals; independent HF and high-cost underground mines will cede ground.
| Company | Positioning | Share/Capacity | Key Metrics | One-liner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jinshi Resources 603050.SH | No. 1 global fluorspar producer: single mines + Baosteel-Jinshi + Mongolia + Jin'ebo HF | Roughly 12.2% global; 1,217,500 tons (2025) | First three quarters of 2026 net profit attributable -21 million; TTM PE roughly 139x; debt ratio 66.6%, operating cash flow -74 million | Trading volume for price has yet to close the loop; expansion discipline is the biggest watch item |
| Baosteel-Jinshi (unlisted JV) | Bayan Obo tailings recovery | 801,100 tons in 2025 | Cost <800 yuan/ton | Far left of the cost curve; a structural variable in Chinese supply |
| Yonghe Co. 605020.SH | Full integration mine-HF-refrigerant + quota | Concentrate roughly 80k tons/year flotation + HF 135,000 tons | 2025 net profit attributable 562 million (+123%); first three quarters of 2026 815 million (+74%); PE-TTM 15.5x (0th percentile of 5 years) | Combines elasticity and valuation value in this landscape |
| Juhua Co. 600160.SH | Quota leader (roughly 38% of third-gen quota, 45.8% of R32 quota) | — | 2025 net profit attributable 3.783 billion (+94%); ROE 19.8% | Largest profit-pool captor; momentum flattening |
| Sanmei Co. 603379.SH | Highest quota purity | — | 2025 gross margin 50.6%, ROE 28.4% | Earning real money but hard to accelerate |
| Mongolrostsvetmet (Mongolian state-owned) | Bor-Undur etc.; source of 86% of China's imports | Mongolia 1.5 million tons | Not disclosed | Main supply line for China's deficit; low transparency |
| Masan (Vietnam, Nui Phao) | Tungsten by-product acid-grade | 147,600 tons in 2025 (roughly 1.5% global) | Not available | Beneficiary of Western de-China supply chains |
| SepFluor (South Africa, Nokeng) | Designed 180,000 tons acid-grade | Below design since start-up | Capex roughly USD 567 per ton of capacity | Africa's main player; slow ramp |
| Koura/Chemours (US/Mexico) | Western full-chain integration | Las Cuevas roughly 600,000–630,000 tons | Chemours 2025 net loss of USD 386 million, debt ratio roughly 97% | Western fluorochemical deep losses are the backdrop for the East–West cost gap |
| Hainan Mining 601969.SH (new entrant) | Proposed 1.454 billion acquisition of Fengrui Fluorite (China's No. 4 reserves, mining license 770k tons/year) | No fluorspar share pre-deal | Restructuring committee deferred review in Nov 2026 | If approved, would restructure Chinese mine-side concentration and the investable universe |
| Zhongxin Fluorine 002915.SZ (tail comparison) | HF + fluoro-fine chemicals, small mines | Negligible | 2025 net margin 1.2%; first three quarters of 2026 turned loss-making | Tail-margin player in this upcycle |
Return quality conclusion: This business overall offers medium returns with severe divergence — the quota-franchise segment (Sanmei ROE 28.4%) and tailings/by-product low-cost resources earn real money; pure mining and independent HF are the epicenter of "revenue growth without profit" (Jinshi saw 2026 revenue surge yet turned loss-making; HF gross margin 5.7%). Valuation position: SW Fluorochemicals index PE 24.78x (18th percentile since Jul 2014), PB 3.05x (40th percentile) — the sector overall is not expensive; single-name divergence is extreme: Yonghe PE-TTM 15.5x (0th percentile of 5 years) is cheapest, Jinshi TTM roughly 139x (due to earnings collapse; percentile meaning is diminished). "Peak cycle × low-percentile sector valuation" implies the quota side's high profitability has been partially priced in but not yet in bubble territory; mine-side narrative stocks are the opposite.
| Scenario | Probability | Price (yuan/ton) | Narrative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bear | 0.30 | 2,800–3,200 | Three-line supply resonance + FSA outperformance + lithium-battery/refrigerant demand destruction; price converges to import parity and the 90th-percentile cost; the "92nd percentile" mean reversion is completed via import parity |
| Base | 0.50 | 3,300–3,650 | Ramp delayed but delivered in 2027H2: gap narrows → mild surplus, pivot drifting slowly from 3,550→3,400, incentive price and cost providing a floor |
| Bull | 0.20 | 3,900–4,300 | Remediation escalates again (Jinshi-type shutdowns broadened) + ramps both below 50% of design + LiPF6 high unit consumption delivered, repeating an Oct-2023-style spike |
| Timing | Event | Directional Impact | Related Debate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-12 | China allocates 2027 HFC quotas (background item, expected marginal increase) | Refrigerant profit pool persists → stable HF demand | D3 |
| 2026-12 | Hainan Mining–Fengrui Fluorite M&A restructuring committee re-review | Approval → restructuring of Chinese mine-side concentration and investable universe | D1 |
| 2027-01 | Karchar full-ramp first-quarter output disclosure | ≥20k tons/month → surplus delivered; <10k tons → shortage persists | D1 |
| 2027-03 | EU PFAS restriction RAC/SEAC opinions | Narrowed version → manageable impact; aggressive version → demand downgrade | D3 |
| 2027-04 | National mine safety inspection season + spring procurement window | Shutdown disruption → upside tail risk in prices | D1 |
| 2027-06 | Gashuun Sukhait–Ganqimaodu railway completion milestone | Opening → Mongolian route cost cut, North China price ceiling moves down | D1 |
| 2027-08 | Interim results: Baosteel-Jinshi output, Minlida ramp, quota holders' earnings | Verifies balance sheet and profit-pool migration | D1/D2 |
| 2027-09 | 2028 HFC quota allocation; Kigali 2029 cuts approaching | Quota profit pool priced for scarcity | D3 |
| 2027-11 | This view's 12-month review (2027 actual balance vs +50k tons) | Tests the "high plateau slow decline" | D1 |
Calling out the value trap: Bullish cycle ≠ worth buying. Pure mine-side names in the bottom-right quadrant (Jinshi currently), independent hydrofluoric acid, and high-cost underground small mines share the same logic — acid-grade fluorspar's "scarcity" narrative has not been delivered as profits at that segment (captured by quota holders, crushed by the left of the cost curve), while valuations have already paid a premium for scarcity; they are the classic "revenue growth without profit" segments of this fluorochemical upcycle. The Chemours Western chain sits in the bottom-left "avoid," an alternative case of both weak cycle and weak returns.
Preferred (real earnings under the base case)
Avoid
| Scenario | Biggest Beneficiaries | Biggest Losers | Logic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bear (2800–3200, p=0.30) | Juhua/Sanmei (quota profits independent of ore prices); Do-Fluoride and other FSA-route players (falling raw material costs) | Jinshi Resources (pure mining-side volume-and-price double hit + high valuation); high-cost small mines/standalone HF | Import parity pricing; mining-side earnings collapse |
| Base (3300–3650, p=0.50) | Yonghe Co. (integration + low valuation); tailings recovery chain (widening cost advantage) | Standalone HF; Western fluorochemicals | Gradual decline from highs; profit pool sustained at both the quota and low-cost ends |
| Bull (3900–4300, p=0.20) | Jinshi Resources (volume and price up together + narrative realized); Yonghe (rising ore prices) | Standalone HF (raw material squeeze); pure quota holders marginally pressured | Production halts expanding, replaying the October 2023 spike |
Upside risks (for those avoiding the mining side): China's safety consolidation escalates beyond expectations and expands to Inner Mongolia/Hebei main production areas; Mongolian port logistics disruption; high unit-consumption assumption for LiPF6 confirmed. Downside risks (for those holding the mining side): the three projects plus Mongolian railway ramp up in resonance in 2027H2; FSA substitution exceeds expectations (Do-Fluoride and others expanding capacity); lithium battery demand destruction and sodium battery substitution; aggressive EU PFAS restrictions implemented; refrigerant exports persistently blocked. Common risk: this report's supply-demand balance is highly sensitive to two parameters — 2027–2028 supply ramp-up and LiPF6 unit consumption (2028E gap range of -5 to +450,000 tonnes) — recommend quarterly recalibration against the catalyst calendar.
Data and Methodology Notes: Production/reserves/trade flows are benchmarked primarily against USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026; cost curve anchors are the SRK independent technical report for Kalchar (HKEX 3833) and company disclosures, with overseas mine cost positions as process-based estimates (flagged for verification); prices are based on Baichuan Yingfu/SunSirs daily assessments and the US average import price (USGS); the demand bridge is a bottom-up estimate (EVTank/GGII/ACMI shipment data × unit consumption coefficients), with unit consumption coefficients given under both stoichiometric and actual-process bases and ranges noted. The balance table is in acid-grade equivalent terms (mine acid-grade + FSA converted to equivalent), with all totals arithmetically cross-checked. Asian parity prices follow IMARC's secondary sourcing (to be verified against first-hand Fastmarkets data).